本话题紧扣校园真实生活场景,引导学生辩证看待学习需求与生态保护的矛盾,培养理性思考与协商解决问题的能力。既考查学生英文书信写作、观点论证与方案设计能力,又渗透生命教育与环保意识,引导学生学会尊重生命、兼顾多方利益,实现语言测评与价值引领、健全人格培育的双重目标。
一、完整命题情境
假设你是花园学校初三学生李华,教室窗外的大树上有几处鸟窝。每天下午四点到五点半,成群的小鸟在窗外叽叽喳喳,十分热闹。现在正值中考备考关键期,部分同学认为鸟鸣声影响学习,向学校提议拆除鸟窝;但也有同学反对这个提议。学校正在征集同学们的意见,请你给负责此事的张老师写一封英文信,说明你的立场与理由,并提出一条解决问题的具体建议。
写作要求:
词数不少于120 词; 文中不得出现真实姓名、校名等个人信息; 信件格式规范,观点明确,理由充分,建议合理可行。
二、阅卷老师满分心理预期
- 审题完整
必须覆盖「立场 + 理由 + 解决方案」全部要点,观点鲜明不模糊; - 立场清晰
支持 / 反对拆除鸟窝的态度明确,理由贴合学生实际与情境; - 逻辑闭环
先表明立场→阐述核心理由→提出可落地的优化方案,层次分明; - 语言得体
书信格式规范,语气礼貌真诚,用词得体,零语法拼写错误; - 立意积极
兼顾学习需求与生态保护、生命教育,传递理性解决问题的态度,契合中考育人导向。
三、高分范文
(一)立场一:反对拆除鸟窝(稳妥标准版)
Dear Mr. Zhang,
I’m writing to share my opinion about the bird nests outside our classroom window.I strongly disagree with the idea of removing the bird nests. First, the birds are our natural friends, and it’s our duty to protect them. Removing their homes would be cruel and go against the idea of caring for life. Second, the bird songs are not just noise; they are also a way to help us relax after long hours of study. Listening to them can reduce our stress and make us feel better.
To solve the problem, I have a suggestion. We can keep the classroom windows closed during the noisy hours, from 4:00 to 5:30 p.m. The glass will block most of the sound, and we can still protect the birds.
I hope my idea will be helpful to you.
Yours sincerely,
Li Hua
(二)立场一:反对拆除鸟窝(语言拔高版)
Dear Mr. Zhang,
I am writing to express my views on the discussion about the bird nests outside our classroom.
Personally, I am completely against the plan to remove the nests. For one thing, these birds have chosen to live near our school, which shows that our environment is friendly and beautiful. It is our responsibility to protect them and respect all living things. For another, instead of being a disturbance, the soft bird songs can be a pleasant break from our busy study life, helping us calm down and stay positive.
Instead of removing the nests, I suggest we adjust our study schedule. We can arrange quiet self-study time in the morning, and leave the afternoon hours for activities that don’t require total silence. This way, we can both protect the birds and keep our study environment quiet.
Thank you for reading my letter.
Yours sincerely,
Li Hua
(三)立场二:支持拆除鸟窝(稳妥标准版)
Dear Mr. Zhang,
I’m writing to talk about the bird nests outside our classroom window.
I think we should remove the nests for the following reasons. First, the birds make a lot of noise from 4:00 to 5:30 p.m., which is a very important time for us to review our lessons and do homework. The noise makes it hard for us to focus on our study, and some students even feel annoyed and can’t finish their work on time. Second, the bird droppings may make the window dirty and unhygienic.
I have a small suggestion. We can move the bird nests to a quiet place far from the classroom building, like the trees near the school gate. In this way, the birds can still live safely, and we can have a quiet study environment.I hope you will consider my suggestion.
Yours sincerely,
Li Hua
(四)立场二:支持拆除鸟窝(语言拔高版)
Dear Mr. Zhang,
I am writing to share my opinion on the bird nests near our classroom.
As a Grade 9 student, I support the idea of relocating the bird nests. At this key stage of preparing for the senior high school entrance examination, every minute of our study time is very precious. The loud bird calls during the afternoon self-study hours greatly disturb our concentration, making it difficult for us to focus on difficult problems or memorize knowledge. Besides, the noise can also make us feel anxious and affect our learning efficiency.
To solve this problem without hurting the birds, I suggest moving the nests to the large trees in the school park. These trees are far from the teaching buildings, so the noise won’t disturb us anymore, and the birds can still live happily in their new home.
Thank you for your understanding.
Yours sincerely,
Li Hua
四、校园建议信类题目 万能高分模板
(一)万能开头(任选其一,礼貌得体,格式规范)
版本 1(稳妥通用版)
Dear Mr./Ms. [Teacher's Last Name],I’m writing to share my opinion about the problem of ______(题目核心话题,如:the bird nests outside our classroom).
版本 2(高级真诚版)
Dear Mr./Ms. [Teacher's Last Name],I am writing to express my views on the discussion about ______(题目核心话题,如:the bird nests near our classroom).
(二)立场 + 理由段模板(支持 / 反对通用,可根据立场调整措辞)
模板 A:反对 / 不支持某方案
Personally, I am against / strongly disagree with the idea of ______(如:removing the bird nests).For one thing, ______(理由 1,如:these birds are our natural friends, and it’s our duty to protect them).For another, ______(理由 2,如:the bird songs are not just noise, but a pleasant break from our busy study life).Besides, ______(补充理由,如:it is our responsibility to respect all living things around us).
模板 B:支持 / 赞同某方案
Personally, I support / agree with the idea of ______(如:relocating the bird nests).First of all, ______(理由 1,如:the noise greatly disturbs our concentration during this important study period).What’s more, ______(理由 2,如:every minute of our review time is precious for the coming exam).Most importantly, ______(补充理由,如:the disturbance makes it hard for us to focus and affects our learning efficiency).
(三)解决方案段模板(核心采分点,必须写具体、可落地)
通用句式(任选其一)
To solve this problem, I have a practical suggestion. We can ______(具体方案,如:keep the classroom windows closed during the noisy hours). This way, we can both ______(双赢结果,如:protect the birds and keep our study environment quiet). Instead of simply ______(如:removing the nests), I suggest we ______(如:move the bird nests to the large trees in the school park). It won’t hurt the birds, and the noise won’t disturb us anymore. I believe we can find a better way. For example, we can ______(如:adjust our study schedule to do quiet work in the morning), so both sides can get what they need.
(四)万能结尾(礼貌收尾,收束全文)
版本 1(稳妥通用版)
Thank you for reading my letter. I hope my suggestion will be helpful to you.Yours sincerely,Li Hua
版本 2(真诚进阶版)
Thank you for your time and understanding. I hope my ideas can contribute to solving this problem.Yours sincerely,Li Hua
(五)加分过渡词 / 短语(直接嵌入文中,让逻辑更丝滑)
表并列 / 补充:Besides, What’s more, Also, Most importantly 表转折:However, Instead of, On the other hand 表举例:For example, For instance, Such as 表目的 / 结果:In this way, So that, To solve this problem
我按「开篇引入→立场 + 理由段→解决方案段→结尾礼貌收尾」的结构,整理了可直接套用的模板,你只需要根据题目替换核心内容即可。